By allowing ads to appear on this site, you support the local businesses who, in turn, support great journalism.
Freshman players don’t make varsity usually:
eli cranor
Syndicated sports columnist Eli Cranor

Dear Athletic Support: A lot of basketball trainers/AAU coaches preach to these kids about being on varsity as a freshman. It seems that you can have kids work super hard and there can be variables that the player can’t overcome to achieve that goal. I have witnessed and have seen kids that felt let down when they don’t make the cut. It lowers their self-esteem too. These players have worked super hard, but when they don’t make the varsity team they just can’t understand why. I wish the trainers and coaches wouldn’t set this as a goal. I’ve also seen some seniors that have put in four years of hard work and still sit the bench all the time, while freshmen are brought up to play varsity. Anyway, just curious what you thought. —Curious Parent Dear Curious: I answered a question recently about why so many kids quit when they make the transition from junior high to varsity athletics. Basically, I argued parents were giving their kids an out and allowing them to quit when the going got tough. But here’s the straight truth — being a freshman is tough! Why? Because there’s a huge disparity in maturity and skill levels between ages fourteen and eighteen. This is a transitional time for kids, and everybody matures at their own pace.

I’m not just talking armpit hair and pimples — their game also matures. We’ve all heard the story of Michael Jordan getting cut from his high school team, which isn’t actually true, by the way; Jor- dan was just demoted to jayvee for his sophomore season. But the lesson remains: If MJ didn’t make the varsity squad his sophomore year, what does that say for the rest of us?

It says hard work pays off.

I know, that might sound cliché. But listen, hard work is quickly becoming a thing of the past. Everything

is just faster these days. We live in an instant society, where most kids greatest goal in life is to go “viral.”

So how do we teach them to slow down?

It starts with the coaches and the trainers you mentioned in your question. It starts with you, too. All of us are so focused on the result, we’ve lost sight of the process.

S e ven- t ime - nat ional- championship-winning coach Nick Saban has a mantra that goes, “Do your job and trust the process.”

What Coach Saban’s getting at here is that there will always be things you cannot control. Athletic contests are wildly complex. The outcome of a game can be altered by something as inexplicable as wind direction, or lately, a star player catching a virus.

When it comes to freshmen players not making the varsity team there are, of course, factors outside of their control. Going back to MJ’s sophomore year; the reason he didn’t make varsity had less to do with his skill set and more to do with his height. MJ was passed over for a 6’7 sophomore center.

But he didn’t quit, and that’s why we’re still telling his story today.

Eli Cranor is a former professional quarterback and coach turned award-winning author. Send questions for “Athletic Support” to eli.cranor@


Sign up for our e-newsletters